All-Time SEOAL MVP Selections
| 1958 - | Bob Risch (Co-MVP) | SR |
| 1960 - | Larry Bainter | SR |
| 1963 - | Robbie Johnson | SR |
| 1965 - | John Gasser | SR |
| 1972 - | Ken Culbertson | SR |
| 1976 - | Scott Gasser | JR |
| 1977 - | Scott Gasser | SR |
| 1985 - | Keith Myers | SR |
| 1987 - | Jimmer Breining | JR |
| 1991 - | Bryan Lambert | SR |
| 1992 - | Greg Crossley (Co-MVP) | SR |
| 1994 - | John Cosgrove | SR |
| 1999 - | Wayne Bateman | SR |
| 2000 - | Joe Conrad | SR |
| 2005 - | Kevin Call | SR |
| 2006 - | Justin Frye (SEOAL North Division) | JR |